上海大学 社会学院,上海 200444
张文宏,教育部长江学者特聘教授,上海大学社会学院教授、博士生导师;
袁佳黎,上海大学社会学院博士候选人;
刘飞,上海大学社会学院博士候选人。
纸质出版日期:2022-05-15,
扫 描 看 全 文
张文宏, 袁佳黎, 刘飞. 特大城市居民的地位认同偏差与公益活动参与[J]. 济南大学学报(社会科学版), 2022,32(3):5-21.
Wenhong ZHANG, Jiali YUAN, Fei LIU. Status Identity Deviation of Mega-city Residents and Their Participation in Public Welfare Activities[J]. JOURNAL OF UNIVERSITY OF JINAN (Social Science Edition), 2022,32(3):5-21.
慈善公益事业是惠及社会大众的事业,是社会文明的重要标志。学界普遍认为社会地位是影响公众公益行为的重要因素之一,在比较主、客二维的社会地位的影响基础上,通过构建地位认同偏差从更多维的视角分析公众的社会地位对公益活动参与的影响。基于2019年度新时代特大城市居民生活状况调查数据的分析,研究发现:第一,个体客观社会地位的提升能够有效促进居民公益行为的参与,其中教育的作用最为显著,主观地位认同并无显著影响;第二,“向上偏差”仅能减少居民捐款捐物的可能性,而“向下偏差”能够提升公众多样化的公益活动参与率,考虑到主观地位认同并不具有显著影响,那么地位认同偏差呈现该结果的原因是:客观社会地位较高(低)群体难以再高(低)估其地位,即客观社会地位较高者更易产生向下偏差,较低者则相反。因此,上述结果反映的是客观社会地位的作用逻辑,表明地位认同偏差并不具有实质意义。以往地位认同偏差研究通常假设主观地位认同而非客观社会地位对个体行为产生影响,但该假设不适用于公益活动参与领域,由于慈善公益行为消耗客观物质资源(经济、时间等资源)的独特属性,畅通特大城市中下层群体的地位跃迁渠道仍是促进慈善公益行为最为有效的方式。
Public welfare is a cause that benefits the public. It is an important symbol of civilization. The academia generally believe that social status is one of the major factors that affect public welfare activities. Based on a comparison of social status from the subjective and the objective perspective
this paper analyzes the impact of social status on the participation in public welfare activities from a multi-dimensional perspective by constructing status identity deviation. Based on the analysis of the survey data of resident living conditions in mega-cities of the New Era in 2019
this study finds that: First
the promotion of objective individual social status can effectively promote the participation of residents in public welfare activities
among which education plays the most significant role
while subjective status identity has no significant influence. Second
"upward deviation" can only reduce the possibility of residents donating money and materials
while "downward deviation" can increase the participation in various public welfare activities. Considering that subjective status identity does not have a significant impact
the reason why status identity deviation leads to this result is that it is difficult for groups with higher (lower) objective social status to estimate their status to be higher (lower)
that is
those with higher objective social status are more likely to have downward deviation
while those with lower social status are the opposite. Therefore
the above results reflect how objective social status functions
which indicates that the deviation of status identity has no substantive significance. Previous studies on status identity deviation usually assumed that subjective status identity rather than objective social status had an impact on individual behavior
but such results suggest that this assumption is not applicable to the participation in public welfare activities. Because of the unique attributes of objective material resources (resources such as economy and time) consumed by public welfare activities
unblocking the status transition channels of the middle and lower classes in mega-cities is still the most effective way to promote public welfare activities.
地位认同偏差公益活动参与客观社会地位主观地位认同
0
浏览量
490
下载量
4
CNKI被引量
关联资源
相关文章
相关作者
相关机构