Gu Wen Xiao Jing Kong Zhuan

came into China from Japan during Qian Long Emperor. Scholars have been discussing it reality since then. Supporters take it as treasure while others try to prove it pseudo from quotations

records and language analysis. Among them

Si Ku Zong Mu Ti Yao

and Zheng Zhen’s opinions are more convincing. Recently

Dunhuang documents proved the reality of

Xiao Jing Zheng Xuan Zhu

. This stimulates some scholars to prove the reality of

Gu Wen Xiao Jing Kong Zhuan

. This paper finds that their evidences are not convincing. Through rechecking the words of Gu Wen Xiao Jing Kong Zhuan

we find some scriptures inherit errors created by scholars in South Song Dynasty when they combined Emperor Xuanzong’s annotation

Sima Guang’s explanation and Fan zuyu’s interpretation. Besides

annotation in Gu

Wen Xiao Jing Kong Zhuan

is different with existing annotation inherited from Han and Tang Dynasty. Thess all prove that

Gu Wen Xiao Jing Kong Zhuan

from Japan is not original Kong anguo’s annotation in Han and Tang Dynasty.